Ideology – We All Have One, Here’s How I Explain Mine

george mcgovern

By Jay Kirell


If you find the following sentence confusing, I do not blame you.

In early 2003 I marched in the streets of New York City to protest the impending war in Iraq, while seven years later I fought in the war in Afghanistan.

When I was in the army I was asked all the time why I was there if I was a liberal. Liberals, everyone knows, hate war and some would even say [looking at you Fox News] that liberals don’t support the troops.

I would have told them about George McGovern and how he was considered the most liberal presidential candidate of the modern era, a guy so liberal he made the word liberal a bad word. I would have told them how he was a pilot on bomber planes that attacked Germany during WWII. I would have told them that, if I thought (a) they knew who George McGovern was, and (b) they would have cared.

So instead I often replied that I was more surprised they, as conservatives, would join the military. This made them pause. Why wouldn’t conservatives join the military? Most military members are conservatives, or if not conservatives, they’ve certainly voted Republican for years.

Then I asked them if they considered themselves Socialists.

What, no? Why would you say that, they’d reply, before the anger set in.

Because, I explained, right now we’re living in the closest example to classic socialism in history.

They did not look convinced.

Look at all the welfare we get —

Welfare! I work for a living, a sergeant once said to me.

I said, yes, sergeant, you do work for a paycheck like everyone else, like everyone inside the army and in the civilian world.

So how’s that welfare?

Well, in the civilian world, when someone gets a job they get a paycheck just like you, and maybe if they’re lucky they get health insurance like we do. But they don’t get money for food. We get a Basic Allowance for Substance, which is basically food stamps for single or married soldiers – that is the one’s that aren’t already getting food stamps to go along with the allowance. Plus, we get money for an apartment and money to move all our stuff into the apartment. Then once a year we get more money to buy new uniforms. And then once we’re out we get college paid for plus a housing stipend!
All of this is on the government dime, and everyone in the military gets it, whether you’re the guy humping 100lbs up a mountain or a pencil-pusher sitting behind a desk all day. Now, I’m not saying we don’t deserve these benefits and entitlements, because we sure as hell do, but don’t deny what they are.

And by then I had convinced most of them I hadn’t joined a conservative enclave, but that they had joined a secret Socialist organization.

And that, I said, is why a liberal joined the army.

Okay, that really wasn’t the reason I joined the army, that was just what I told them. I had no idea how much the military literally takes care of almost everything (short of better pay) for a service member. It’s rightly deserved, but part of my ideology, and part of what makes me a liberal, is that I want the rest of the country – or at least the part that needs it – to have the same safety net that I did.

Yeah, I fought for my country and all that. I risked my life. I But what was I fighting for when people in my country are still struggling?

Now that I’m out of the army I’ll be set up for success thanks to all the benefits I have coming to me. And that security is a feeling that I was unprepared for. It left me feeling guilty.

And that guilt about my own privilege and what I have, even if it’s meager by normal standards, is what makes me a liberal.

, ,

2 Comments on “Ideology – We All Have One, Here’s How I Explain Mine”

  1. Allen Slattery, former US Navy Sailor, 2000-2005.
    November 26, 2013 at 6:08 am #

    So, let me get this straight. You joined the Army to prove a point? That’s what it seems like to me. At least, that’s what you’ve been doing since you got out. Well, I have some news for you. We “conservatives” joined the military out of a sense of duty to serve our country, not get the “freebies” that are attached to military service. Yes, we accepted that we would have lower pay, but better benefits than most people. However, the better benefits only matter when you’re not DEAD! That’s the difference between we military people, and the majority of the civilian world. We VOLUNTARILY sign up to “work” in a “job” that could very easily leave us DEAD! We VOLUNTARILY sign up to “work” in a “job” where many other people are trying to make us end up DEAD! By the way, the very fact that it is voluntary service means the military is not socialism. We sign a contract where we give up the most basic rights we defend. When we were active duty, we had no right to speak out against our President, even if we thought he was in the wrong. We had to give up the basic right to freedom of choice. We followed orders, even if those orders put us in harms way. We give up 4 or more years of our lives to a life of servitude. Yes, we accepted these things when we voluntarily signed up to join the US Armed Forces, upon the promise of having some benefits when we were discharged honorably, such as the G.I. Bill (which we partially pay for), college fund, etc, etc. There is one thing in which we conservatives don’t do though, and that is take advantage of the system after we get out, as you are doing with the food stamps as you point out in one of your later posts. I’m sure you make a fair amount of money in writing your blogs. I’m sure you are making good use of the G.I. Bill and/or College Fund going to a pretty decent university such as Hofstra. Are there truly that many people in the civilian world that need a social safety net? No way!! There are sometimes 2 and 3 generations of families that are on welfare for their entire lives when they are perfectly capable to work. Welfare programs are filled with single mothers that are rewarded with more money to have another child. More and more these days, people are taking advantage of their food stamp benefits by selling them for cash. Are they in need of food stamps if they are selling them for cash? No way!! The simple fact is, everyone is an individual. Every case needs to be treated differently. Maybe if it took as long as a year to decide who “needed” benefits and who didn’t, we wouldn’t be in this mess in the first place. As to you sir, I think you are just as bad as the rest of them. Your feeling of entitlement is as bad as the welfare mom who won’t get a job because she makes enough to live comfortably on welfare.


    June 15, 2014 at 6:53 pm #

    My partner and I stumbled over here by a different website and thought I might check things
    out. I like what I see so now i’m following you.
    Look forward to looking over your web page for a second


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: